

The ACAS Code Is Changing: The Growing Role of Workplace Mediation?
Proposed changes to the ACAS Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures place early resolution, facilitated conversations and workplace mediation firmly in the spotlight. What does this mean for HR professionals and how can organisations prepare?
Workplace conflict is one of the most challenging issues facing HR professionals. Disagreements between colleagues, strained relationships between employees and managers, communication breakdowns and unresolved grievances can have a significant impact on employee wellbeing, organisational culture and business performance.
Traditionally, many workplace concerns have been managed through formal grievance and disciplinary procedures. While these processes remain an essential part of ensuring fairness and accountability, they do not always provide the most effective means of resolving the underlying conflict or repairing damaged working relationships. That approach is increasingly being recognised as something that needs to change.
In July 2026, Acas published a draft revised Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures, proposing a greater emphasis on resolving workplace concerns early and informally wherever appropriate.
For HR and Employee Relations professionals, the proposed changes represent an important development. If adopted, the revised Code would bring guidance on informal resolution, including mediation and facilitated conversations, into the main body of the statutory Code for the first time.
The consultation closed on 23 September 2026, and ACAS is currently reviewing responses. The revised Code is expected to come into effect in 2027, subject to the approval process.
Although the changes remain in draft form, they provide a timely opportunity for HR professionals to consider whether their organisation's approach to workplace conflict is sufficiently focused on early intervention, constructive communication and effective resolution.
A Changing Approach to Workplace Conflict
The proposed revisions to the ACAS Code reflect a growing recognition that not every workplace concern needs to become a formal grievance or disciplinary matter.
The draft Code encourages employers and workers to speak to one another with the aim of resolving concerns early and preventing unnecessary escalation. It also emphasises the importance of dealing with issues promptly and avoiding unreasonable delays in conversations, meetings or decisions. For HR professionals, this represents an important shift in emphasis.
Formal procedures are necessary in many circumstances. They provide structure, ensure that allegations are properly considered and help employers meet their legal obligations. However, formal processes can sometimes create an adversarial environment in which individuals become increasingly focused on defending their position rather than addressing the underlying problem.
The draft Code recognises the value of alternative approaches to resolution. It encourages employers to consider informal discussions, mediation and facilitated conversations where appropriate, including at different stages of a disciplinary or grievance process.
For HR teams, the question is therefore not simply whether an organisation has appropriate grievance and disciplinary policies in place. It is whether managers and HR professionals have the skills, confidence and resources to identify workplace conflict early and consider whether a constructive conversation might achieve a better outcome.
Why Early Intervention Matters
Workplace conflict rarely appears overnight. It may begin with a misunderstanding, an inappropriate comment, a difference in working styles, an unresolved disagreement about responsibilities or a breakdown in communication between colleagues. If these issues are not addressed, they can become increasingly entrenched.
Employees may become frustrated, disengaged or reluctant to communicate. Managers may find themselves spending disproportionate amounts of time managing interpersonal difficulties. Colleagues may begin taking sides, affecting the wider team. Eventually, what might initially have been resolved through a relatively straightforward conversation can develop into a formal grievance, disciplinary investigation, sickness absence or an employment dispute.
ACAS research estimates that formal disciplinary and grievance procedures cost UK employers approximately £2.36 billion annually. By comparison, the estimated annual cost of informal resolution is around £250 million.
These figures highlight the potential benefits of addressing workplace concerns before they escalate into more complex and costly processes. However, the costs of unresolved conflict extend beyond the financial implications of formal procedures.
HR professionals and managers may spend hours investigating complaints, preparing documentation, attending meetings and managing ongoing tensions. Productivity can suffer, employee morale can deteriorate and organisations may lose valuable employees who no longer feel able to continue working in the same environment.
The Proposed ACAS Guidance on Mediation and Facilitated Conversations
One of the most significant developments in the draft revised Code is the inclusion of a dedicated section on mediation and facilitated conversations. Paragraphs 90–95 address these processes specifically, recognising their potential to resolve workplace concerns and improve working relationships.
The draft Code explains that mediation involves an independent third party helping those involved resolve a concern. The third party should be an accredited mediator or trained facilitator who is impartial and does not take sides.
It also recognises that mediation and facilitated conversations:
·Can be suggested by anyone at any stage of a process, or afterwards.
·Are voluntary and confidential.
·Do not require participants to accept proposed solutions.
·Can be particularly beneficial in resolving problems associated with working relationships.
·May be appropriate during a formal disciplinary or grievance process, in which case the formal procedure should be paused if mediation is agreed.
The draft Code also recognises that mediation is not appropriate in every situation. For example, it may not be suitable where a factual determination of statutory rights is required, where a decision needs to be made by someone else, or where a substantial power imbalance cannot be managed safely.
For HR professionals, this guidance provides a useful framework for considering when mediation might be appropriate and how it can be incorporated into an organisation's approach to managing workplace conflict. Importantly, mediation is not presented as a replacement for formal procedures. Rather, it is recognised as an additional tool which may enable employers and employees to resolve concerns more effectively in appropriate circumstances.
What Does This Mean for HR Professionals?
The proposed changes place greater emphasis on the ability of HR professionals and managers to recognise opportunities for informal resolution. This may require a different approach to some workplace concerns. Rather than immediately considering which formal procedure should be followed, HR professionals may need to ask:
·What is the underlying issue?
·Is this primarily a relationship or communication problem?
·Have the individuals involved had an opportunity to discuss their concerns?
·Could a facilitated conversation help them understand each other's perspectives?
·Is the situation suitable for mediation?
·Would an independent mediator provide a more appropriate environment for resolving the dispute?
·Are there circumstances which require formal investigation or management action instead?
These questions require judgement, experience and confidence. HR professionals need to understand not only the procedural requirements of grievance and disciplinary processes, but also the dynamics of workplace conflict and the different approaches available to resolve it.
The ability to facilitate a constructive conversation can be particularly valuable where employees have become reluctant to communicate directly, where previous discussions have failed or where the involvement of a manager has inadvertently contributed to the conflict.
The Importance of Giving Employees an Opportunity to Be Heard
One of the most valuable aspects of mediation and facilitated conversations is the opportunity they provide for individuals to explain their concerns and feel that they have been genuinely heard. When workplace relationships deteriorate, communication can become increasingly defensive. Individuals may feel that their concerns have been dismissed, that they have been misunderstood or that their perspective has not been properly considered. This can lead to frustration, resentment and a growing reluctance to engage with the other person.
A facilitated conversation provides a structured opportunity for participants to explain how they have experienced the situation, what they consider to have gone wrong and what they would like to see change. The facilitator or mediator ensures that everyone has an opportunity to contribute and encourages participants to listen to one another without interruption or judgement.
This does not mean that participants must agree with each other's account of events. Nor does it require either individual to accept responsibility for something they do not believe they have done. The objective is to create an environment in which different perspectives can be understood and the underlying issues explored constructively.
As Nick Cheshire, Lead Workplace Mediator at Harbour Mediation, explains:
"One of the most important aspects of workplace mediation is giving people the opportunity to be heard. When working relationships have deteriorated, individuals can become so focused on defending their own position that meaningful communication becomes almost impossible. Mediation creates the space for people to explain how they see the situation, understand the perspective of the other person and start considering how they might move forward constructively."
For HR professionals, recognising the importance of this process can be fundamental to determining whether an informal conversation or mediation is likely to be effective.
Facilitated Conversations: A Valuable Skill for HR Teams
Not every workplace disagreement requires an external mediator. HR professionals and managers can play an important role in resolving concerns at an early stage by facilitating conversations between employees.
A facilitated conversation is generally less formal than workplace mediation. It may involve an HR professional or manager helping individuals discuss their concerns, clarify misunderstandings and agree practical steps for moving forward. The facilitator does not necessarily need to be a professionally accredited mediator, although appropriate training in facilitation and conflict management is important.
The skills required include:
·Active listening.
·Asking open and impartial questions.
·Managing difficult conversations.
·Recognising and managing emotions.
·Maintaining neutrality.
·Encouraging participants to consider different perspectives.
·Identifying underlying interests rather than simply focusing on positions.
·Helping individuals develop practical solutions.
·Knowing when a conversation is no longer appropriate and when independent mediation or a formal process may be necessary.
These are not simply communication skills. They are conflict management skills which can help HR professionals intervene effectively when workplace relationships begin to deteriorate. A well-facilitated conversation can prevent misunderstandings from becoming entrenched and may allow employees to resolve their concerns without the need for a formal grievance.
However, there will be circumstances where HR professionals become aware of the limits of their role. Where the HR professional is involved in the dispute, where there is a significant power imbalance or where employees do not feel comfortable discussing the issues with someone within the organisation, an independent external mediator may be more appropriate.
When Should HR Consider an External Workplace Mediator?
There will be situations where informal conversations facilitated internally are unlikely to be sufficient. External workplace mediation can be particularly valuable where:
·Relationships have significantly deteriorated. Employees may no longer be able to communicate constructively without the assistance of an independent third party.
·Previous attempts at resolution have failed. Where informal conversations have not resolved the issues, a more structured mediation process may provide an opportunity to explore the conflict in greater depth.
·The dispute involves a manager or senior employee. Employees may be reluctant to discuss their concerns openly where the other participant has managerial authority or influence over their employment.
·The HR team is involved in the dispute. Where HR has already played a role in managing the situation, an independent mediator can provide a neutral environment in which participants have confidence in the impartiality of the process.
·The conflict is affecting the wider organisation. Where workplace tensions are beginning to affect other employees, productivity or team morale, early intervention may help prevent further escalation.
·The parties need to continue working together. Mediation can help individuals establish a more constructive professional relationship, even where they do not agree on everything that has happened.
Confidentiality and the Importance of an Independent Process
Confidentiality is one of the fundamental features of workplace mediation. Employees may be reluctant to discuss sensitive issues openly if they are concerned that their comments will be repeated, used against them or become part of a formal employment process. An independent mediation process provides a confidential environment in which individuals can explore their concerns and consider possible solutions.
The mediator does not represent the employer or either employee. They do not make findings, determine responsibility or impose an outcome. Instead, the mediator facilitates the discussion, manages the process and helps participants identify practical ways forward.
The confidentiality arrangements are explained and agreed before mediation begins, including any appropriate exceptions. Confidentiality should not be confused with legal privilege or used to prevent employees from exercising their statutory rights or raising concerns which require formal action.
For HR professionals, understanding these distinctions is important when deciding whether mediation is appropriate and explaining the process to employees.
Moving Beyond the Grievance: Rebuilding Working Relationships
One of the limitations of formal grievance procedures is that they are primarily concerned with investigating and determining complaints. Even where a grievance is resolved, the relationship between the individuals involved may remain damaged. Employees may return to work with unresolved frustrations, a lack of trust and little confidence that anything has fundamentally changed.
Mediation offers a different approach. Rather than concentrating exclusively on what happened in the past, the process encourages participants to consider what needs to change to make their working relationship more effective in the future. The discussion may explore communication, professional behaviour, expectations, responsibilities, working arrangements and the practical steps required to rebuild confidence.
As Nick Cheshire observes:
"The objective of workplace mediation is not necessarily to restore a relationship to exactly how it was before the disagreement. Sometimes that is neither possible nor realistic. The important thing is to help people identify a constructive way forward, establish clearer expectations and develop a working relationship that allows them to move on professionally."
For HR professionals, this forward-focused approach can be particularly valuable where employees need to continue working together. The outcome does not necessarily require friendship or complete agreement. Sometimes the most successful outcome is simply a professional relationship in which individuals can communicate effectively, cooperate and perform their respective roles.
Preparing Your HR Team for the Changing Landscape
The proposed revisions to the ACAS Code provide an opportunity for organisations to review their existing approach to workplace conflict. HR professionals may wish to consider:
·Reviewing existing policies and procedures. Do current grievance and disciplinary policies provide sufficient opportunity for informal resolution before formal procedures are initiated?
·Developing early intervention strategies. Are managers and HR professionals equipped to identify workplace conflict before it escalates?
·Providing training in facilitated conversations. Do HR professionals have the confidence and practical skills required to facilitate difficult conversations constructively?
·Understanding when mediation is appropriate. Are HR teams able to recognise when internal facilitation may be sufficient and when an independent external mediator would be more suitable?
·Establishing access to external mediation. Does the organisation have a process for accessing independent workplace mediation when internal resolution is unlikely to be effective?
·Encouraging a constructive organisational culture. Do employees feel able to raise concerns early, knowing that they will be taken seriously and that the organisation will seek to address them fairly?
These are practical steps which can help organisations prepare for the changing emphasis on early resolution, irrespective of when the revised Code ultimately comes into effect.
Workplace Mediation Training for HR Professionals
At Harbour Mediation, we recognise the increasingly important role HR professionals play in identifying, managing and resolving workplace conflict. Our workplace mediation training is designed to provide HR professionals, managers and business leaders with practical skills and techniques for facilitating constructive conversations between employees.
The training focuses on the principles and techniques of mediation, adapted for use by HR professionals in early intervention situations. It includes practical guidance on:
·Understanding workplace conflict and its underlying causes.
·Recognising when early intervention is appropriate.
·Preparing for a facilitated conversation.
·Establishing ground rules and creating a safe environment.
·Active listening and effective questioning.
·Managing difficult conversations and emotional responses.
·Encouraging employees to consider different perspectives.
·Identifying practical solutions and agreeing a way forward.
·Recognising when independent workplace mediation may be more appropriate.
The objective is not to turn HR professionals into professional mediators. It is to equip them with the skills and confidence to manage workplace conflict more effectively, intervene earlier and help employees resolve concerns constructively wherever appropriate.
Training can be tailored to the needs of individual organisations and delivered in person or online.
Independent Workplace Mediation with Harbour Mediation
Where workplace conflict has become more complex, relationships have deteriorated or internal attempts at resolution have been unsuccessful, independent workplace mediation can provide a valuable opportunity to address the situation constructively.
Harbour Mediation provides workplace mediation services to employers and organisations across Devon, the South West and throughout the UK. Led by Nick Cheshire, a CMC Registered Workplace Mediator, Harbour Mediation combines professional mediation expertise with more than 20 years of commercial and legal experience.
Our approach is practical, impartial and forward-focused. We provide individual confidential pre-mediation meetings with participants, followed by an independently facilitated joint mediation meeting, giving employees the opportunity to discuss their concerns and explore a constructive way forward. Mediation can be delivered in person or through secure online meetings, depending on the circumstances.
For HR professionals, independent mediation can provide an additional resource when managing workplace conflict, particularly where internal facilitation may not be appropriate or where a more structured process is required.
The proposed changes to the ACAS Code reflect an important development in the way workplace concerns are approached.
For HR professionals, the message is clear: resolving workplace conflict is not simply about managing formal procedures. It is also about recognising opportunities for early intervention, encouraging constructive communication and providing employees with appropriate opportunities to resolve their concerns. Mediation and facilitated conversations can play an important role in this process.
By developing the skills required to manage difficult conversations, recognising when independent mediation is appropriate and creating a culture which encourages early resolution, HR professionals can help organisations reduce unnecessary escalation, protect working relationships and improve employee wellbeing.
About the Author
Nick Cheshire is an experienced CMC accredited workplace and commercial mediator and the director of Harbour Mediation.
Harbour Mediation provides workplace mediation services and practical workplace mediation training for HR professionals, managers and business leaders. Contact Harbour Mediation to discuss workplace mediation, early intervention training or how independent mediation could support your organisation.
If you are dealing with a workplace conflict and would like to discuss, in confidence, the suitability and timing of mediation as an option going forward, please contact Nick Cheshire at nick.cheshire@harbour-mediation.com.
Harbour Mediation Limited - Privacy Policy
Civil, Commercial & Workplace Mediation, UK & International




© 2026 Harbour Mediation Limited All rights reserved



